Preuves d'avis suspects — HostelPunk
El Cielo Oaxaca

Oaxaca · Mexico

El Cielo Oaxaca

Punk Score
8% ATROCE
Confiance élevée 1,523 avis
≈100 possiblement achetés
Sérieusement, ne dors pas ici, s'il te plaît.
Preuves d'avis suspects ≈100 possiblement achetés

≈100 possiblement achetés · 885 avis au top scannés

Expliquer le fonctionnement

On compare le nombre de mots de chaque avis 5★ à la distribution globale. Les auberges où un nombre anormalement élevé d'avis au top de la note sont suspicieusement courts — bien en dessous de la longueur typique — commencent à ressembler à du staff (ou à un service de boost de fiche) qui gonfle le score avec des compliments jetables.

Le détecteur repère les avis à la fois au top de la note et en dessous d'un seuil de longueur, puis estime combien ne devraient statistiquement pas exister. Pour cette auberge, on a scanné 885 avis au top de la note et 0% étaient suspicieusement courts.

Z-score de longueur : 7.32. Un z-score mesure la distance entre la distribution des longueurs d'avis 5★ de cette auberge et la moyenne globale, en écarts-types. 0 = parfaitement typique. 1–2 = légèrement inhabituel mais dans le bruit normal. 3–5 = fortement anormal. Au-delà de 10, le motif est si loin de la norme globale qu'il est en pratique impossible à obtenir naturellement.

C'est une heuristique, pas un verdict — ça met en avant les auberges à regarder de plus près, pas une preuve de fraude. Lisez les avis ci-dessous et jugez par vous-même.

  1. Acheté confirmé 43 mots 20%
    Trace du signal
    • Récompense liée à un avis for good review

    Horrible experience, absolutely inattentive staff, smallest rooms i’ve ever seen, dirty showers and toilets. Manager tried to pressure us for good reviews with money, this explains their good ratings.. absolutely sort the reviews by worst to have an honest picture of the place…

  2. Acheté confirmé 72 mots 66%
    Trace du signal
    • Récompense liée à un avis reviews in exchange for luggage storage and give a free beer

    It's a nice enough hostel. Not the best but not the worst. The beds have curtains and I slept well there. They ask for reviews in exchange for luggage storage and give a free beer if you follow their socials, which I find off-putting. Free breakfast was nice. Toilets and showers can use improvement and there are not enough PowerPoints in the room. Not particularly social but I only stayed one night.

    Australia FEMALE 25-30
  3. Acheté confirmé 93 mots 20%
    Trace du signal
    • Récompense liée à un avis money back we would have had to write a good review

    ABSOLUTELY AVOID THIS PLACE! This hostel has been the worst experience in hostels i’ve had. the place is dirty, the mattresses are stained and riddled with bedbugs, the showers smell like something died in it and downstairs people are going on wild “meditation” trips. the staff are rude. their response to us leaving in the middle of the night was: “perfecto”… to get our money back we would have had to write a good review on hostelworld and google. to sum up: they buy their good reviews and the place is a dump.

  4. Acheté confirmé 98 mots 69%
    Trace du signal
    • Récompense liée à un avis for good review
    • Pression pour laisser un avis told me a deal. Free storage for good review

    The guy from the nightshift is great but the other part of the stuff .. unfriendly and cold. The hostel wanted me to pay 150 mxn (8usd) to store my backpack for 2 days - ok no. But than they also wanted me to pay for storage until my bus at the evening! Only storage at check-in day is for free. Never, never in 47 countries I should have payed for storage at checkout day! The owner told me a deal. Free storage for good review. No way. only honest reviews! pillows are stinky and dirt behind beds.

    Germany FEMALE 25-30
  5. Acheté confirmé 147 mots 20%
    Trace du signal
    • Récompense liée à un avis money back in exchange for a positive, dishonest review

    We arrived at the hostel and were ushered into a completely different hostel with no explanation. We were taken to a separate building further down the road that was not advertised and had none of the facilities including; pool, 24hr security, ping pong etc. The staff will say it’s a “nice room that we’ll like”, it’s not, it’s a separate building and honestly felt like a scam. Shame because the hostel we booked looked alright when we looked around. Worst of all, when we requested an explanation, we were met with radio silence, after a bit of persistent chasing we were offered part of our money back in exchange for a positive, dishonest review…anyway, here’s the honest review! If you do get to stay in the actual hostel, it might have the potential to hit your expectations. Only positive was the lady on the desk was friendly.

    England COUPLE 31-40
  6. Acheté confirmé 522 mots 20%
    Trace du signal
    • Récompense liée à un avis reviews. We still want a full refund
    • Pression pour laisser un avis told your employee that all 4 of us had to post a 5-star review
    • Plainte sur l’authenticité des avis reviews on the web are bought

    THIS IS WHAT I WROTE TO THE MANAGER: We booked a 4-bed-dorm from the 7th-9th of august through Hostelworld. When we arrived at 12pm on the 7th there was no space for us to put the luggage in a safe storage. Later when we came back to check in the staff ignored us and they didn’t explain any of the communal spaces or amenities. The door of our dorm didn’t even have a key, felt very unsafe to leave our belongings there. We got approached by several men trying to sell us jewelry and stickers. We felt that there were people taking drugs and that made us feel very unsafe, especially as there were signs everywhere saying that we couldn’t even bring alcohol to the hostel. We came back to the hostel in the evening and wanted to shower. The shower was unspeakable, it smelled horrible and was dirty, also couldn’t lock the shower door!!! This was the first time that we really looked at our beds. What we encountered was terrible. There was a huge stain on one of the mattresses, another bed didn’t even have covers and we got claustrophobic in there. No working power sockets in the walls to charge our phones… We decided to look at your reviews again and found out about some bed bugs traveling around your hostel recently. That was the final straw and we decided we couldn’t stay here any longer. As we left your staff asked us why and as we explained our reason for leaving his only answer was „perfecto“ Today we came back to cancel our second night and we had planned to tell your employees about our experience but on the end I don’t think it’s their fault which is why we are letting you know personally. We first got told that there was no way to get any of the money back. Then we found out that if we left a 5-star review on google maps we could get half of the money of 1 night back (400 pesos). We were so devastated that we decided to go through with it. I posted a 5-star review but then you told your employee that all 4 of us had to post a 5-star review in order to get the 400 pesos!! We did it, got the money and left as soon as we could. It’s beyond unbelievable what you are doing. all the good reviews on the web are bought and false, we later even read some reviews saying that this also happened to them so we know that we’re not the first ones this has happened to. We feel cheated on and this behavior is disgusting, you should be ashamed of yourself. We have now decided that we do not support this behavior and took down our good reviews. We still want a full refund, and we really feel like posting an honest review about our experience. Nothing exaggerated but the honest truth. We’re also really thinking about contacting Hostelworld and letting them know about your behavior, safety problems and scam. have a good evening. NEVER GOT AN ANSWER

  7. Acheté confirmé 99 mots 20%
    Trace du signal
    • Récompense liée à un avis pays people to leave a good review

    SORT REVIEWS BY LOWEST! the manager pays people to leave a good review and cancels the booking on hostelworld to avoid bad reviews. there were no lockers for our luggage before checking in, we didnt get a key for our room, showers smelled really bad and were dirty, staff didnt care, no one showed us any of the amenities or gave us any kind of welcome or introduction, mattresses were stained. There were people trying to sell you their jewelry or art inside the hostel. Wouldn't recommend, you can get much nicer places for the same price (even AirBnB's)

  8. Suspicieusement court 48 mots 46%
    Trace du signal
    • Pression pour laisser un avis asked us to leave a 5 star review

    Below par hostel, rooms were not nearly as nice as others of this price. Staff asked us to leave a 5 star review in exchange for leaving our bags in the lobby area or they’d charge us which we thought was really weird. But location was a plus

    England FEMALE 18-24
  9. Suspicieusement court 73 mots 46%
    Trace du signal
    • Pression pour laisser un avis told us to pay 120 pesos per bag or leave a 5 star review

    Overall it was okay, however it was very loud and every morning children running inside the hostel. There was also a cat roaming around the room and eating trash from the bins. The most important thing is that the majority of reviews are probably nothonest because when we wanted to leave our bags in storage they told us to pay 120 pesos per bag or leave a 5 star review for free storage.

    Netherlands FEMALE 25-30
  10. Suspicieusement court 87 mots 43%
    Trace du signal
    • Plainte sur l’authenticité des avis paid or “gave a review

    Pros: Location. Cons: Private room not cleaned (or poorly) from prior guests, sheets were dirty, shower had hair left on walls, room hot - one small fan on high ceiling roof, room very loud from street traffic, pool dirty/murky (first pool in Latin America we refused to get in), we could not store luggage for a couple of hours after checkout unless we paid or “gave a review”. (Makes me question the other 10/10 reviews). Wouldn’t return or recommended to others. Happy to leave after 2 nights.

    Australia FEMALE 31-40
  11. Suspicieusement court 289 mots 20%
    Trace du signal
    • Plainte sur l’authenticité des avis DON’T TRUST THIS HOSTEL’S REVIEWS

    DON’T TRUST THIS HOSTEL’S REVIEWS! Worst customer service ever. Noisy. Musty smell. Bathroom so small my knees were touching the wall when sitting on the toilet. I’m 5’8”. Not a giant. Customer service was SO bad and the manager (Sonia) SO rude that it made me extremely uncomfortable to even consider staying. I seldom write reviews, but this is worth mentioning. Especially since the manager threatened us to get us to remove a negative review. My friend had checked in the night before and was pretty much dismissed by the guy at reception. She mistakenly said the reservation was through Booking instead of Hostelworld and was immediately ignored and told to go find the right hostel… at 10pm. When I joined her the next day, within 3 mins of sitting in the lobby the manager came to see me and was verbally aggressive, giving me an ultimatum to either leave the premises or make my friend take down the review she had written, which we did but they still forced us to leave. We requested a refund for the 3 out of 4 nights we didn’t stay - since they forced us to leave. They only offered us the equivalent of 2 nights and CALLED THE COPS on us when we tried to get the rest of our money. Unfortunately we caved so as not to deal with local police force. Never ever in my life have I encountered such HORRIBLE customer service. The only saving grace was one of the receptionists, a girl named Ana, who was very apologetic for how we were treated. Note, I also tried to leave this review on Hostelworld directly, but they cancelled my booking to prevent me from doing it. STAY AWAY!

  12. Suspicieusement court 1 mot 100%

    Todo

    Mexico
  13. Suspicieusement court 1 mot 100%

    Cool

  14. Suspicieusement court 1 mot 100%
    Traduit en anglais

    recommended

    Spain FEMALE 25-30
  15. Suspicieusement court 1 mot 100%

    beautiful

    Australia FEMALE 31-40
  16. Suspicieusement court 1 mot 100%

    Beautiful

    Chile FEMALE
  17. Suspicieusement court 1 mot 100%
    Traduit en anglais

    100% recommended

    Colombia FEMALE 31-40
  18. Suspicieusement court 2 mots 100%
    Traduit en anglais

    Everything is perfect!

    Andorra ALLFEMALEGROUP 25-30
  19. Suspicieusement court 2 mots 100%

    Muy bien

  20. Suspicieusement court 2 mots 100%

    Todo bien

  21. Suspicieusement court 2 mots 90%

    Ubicación Desayuno

    Mexico
  22. Suspicieusement court 2 mots 100%

    Great hostel

    England FEMALE 25-30
  23. Suspicieusement court 2 mots 100%

    Excelente ubicacion

    Mexico
  24. Suspicieusement court 2 mots 100%
    Traduit en anglais

    It 's a beautiful hostel .

    France MALE 25-30
  25. Suspicieusement court 2 mots 100%

    lovely staff!

    Australia MALE 25-30

Avis natifs HostelPunk

Notes de terrain directes

Laisser un avis

Aucun avis HostelPunk natif pour l'instant. Soyez le premier signal.

Réserver ici : Hostelworld à partir de ≈$16 Booking.com Prix HW à partir de aujourd'hui

Tags

Petits plus

🚲 Location de vélos

Équipements

🏊 Piscine 🍳 CUISINIÈRE 👕 Buanderie 🔥 BBQ 🌅 Terrasse extérieure 🌿 Jardin 🍳 Petit-déjeuner 🍺 Bar ☕ Café
Autres équipements (40)
Parking vélos Adaptateurs Consigne bagages Téléphone ligne directe Service de fax Réception 24h/24 Comptoir tours et voyages Bureau de change Ménage Accès Internet Échange de livres DVD Jeux de société Billard Wi-Fi Ping-pong Smart TV Check-in / check-out express Check-out tardif Draps inclus Lampe de lecture Sèche-cheveux Ventilateur de plafond Prises de recharge Coin thé et café Fontaine d'eau filtrée Minibar Casiers sécurisés Sécurité 24h/24 Vidéosurveillance dans les espaces communs Extincteurs Trousses de premiers secours Douches chaudes Salle commune Plans de ville gratuits Wi-Fi gratuit Accès Internet gratuit Visite de la ville gratuite Casiers sécurisés gratuits Vues panoramiques

Unusual phrases