Ho Chi Minh · Vietnam
Saigon Rooftops Hostel
Preuves d'avis suspects
≈556 possiblement achetés · 4007 avis au top scannés
Expliquer le fonctionnement
On compare le nombre de mots de chaque avis 5★ à la distribution globale. Les auberges où un nombre anormalement élevé d'avis au top de la note sont suspicieusement courts — bien en dessous de la longueur typique — commencent à ressembler à du staff (ou à un service de boost de fiche) qui gonfle le score avec des compliments jetables.
Le détecteur repère les avis à la fois au top de la note et en dessous d'un seuil de longueur, puis estime combien ne devraient statistiquement pas exister. Pour cette auberge, on a scanné 4007 avis au top de la note et 0% étaient suspicieusement courts.
Z-score de longueur : 20.14. Un z-score mesure la distance entre la distribution des longueurs d'avis 5★ de cette auberge et la moyenne globale, en écarts-types. 0 = parfaitement typique. 1–2 = légèrement inhabituel mais dans le bruit normal. 3–5 = fortement anormal. Au-delà de 10, le motif est si loin de la norme globale qu'il est en pratique impossible à obtenir naturellement.
C'est une heuristique, pas un verdict — ça met en avant les auberges à regarder de plus près, pas une preuve de fraude. Lisez les avis ci-dessous et jugez par vous-même.
-
Acheté confirméTrace du signal
-
Récompense liée à un avis
free beer 5-8 encouraged people to go upstairs and mix up. 10/10
-
Pression pour laisser un avis
encouraged people to go upstairs and mix up. 10/10
Had such a good stay here. The staff were great and very nice. It was very social and the free beer 5-8 encouraged people to go upstairs and mix up. 10/10
Ireland FEMALE 25-30 -
Récompense liée à un avis
-
Acheté confirméTrace du signal
-
Récompense liée à un avis
reviews are because of this but saw the bartender ask for a rating for a free beer
Great location and super nice staff! The bathroom and the facilities could definitely be nice for the price. Also, not saying all the good reviews are because of this but saw the bartender ask for a rating for a free beer.
USA FEMALE 25-30 -
Récompense liée à un avis
-
Acheté confirméTrace du signal
-
Récompense liée à un avis
reviews it was not our level of hygiene. We didn’t get a full refund
We originally booked this hostel but cancelled after the first night. The sheets and duvet were visibly covered in dirt on two of our beds. The bathroom has visible black mould on the tiles and small miniscule bugs crawling on the toilet and sink. While atmosphere and staff seem great hence the good reviews it was not our level of hygiene. We didn’t get a full refund after a staff member reviewed our claims and reported back it “was not that bad”. Most hostels would argue they are up to standard. Fine if you want to party and crash.
-
Récompense liée à un avis
-
Acheté confirméTrace du signal
-
Récompense liée à un avis
rating I’ve seen on hostel world, which is because they give free beer
Not all it’s cracked up to be. Got the best rating I’ve seen on hostel world, which is because they give free beer for good reviews. Got a nice rooftop bar but there’s no lights and it’s essentially an oven. They didn’t empty our bathroom bin for 3 days so it stank of sweaty shit. Staff are very friendly but there’s no reps so it’s hard to get an atmosphere. Value for money is very good tbf as you get a free beer and breakfast every day. Facilities are good it’s got a ps5 and the rooftop bar. Location is decent it’s very close to all the bars and walking distance to the war museum. Also we got gas the worst fried rice ever in Hoi an so would avoid it if you can.
-
Récompense liée à un avis
-
Acheté confirméTrace du signal
-
Récompense liée à un avis
reviews which should of been a red flag 🚩 Rooftop was nice and the free beer
We stayed here for 2 nights and I got a total of 2 hours sleep altogether. The hostel is so noisy as they do a pub crawl every night at 11:30pm so people come in and out of the room until 5/6am. The bathroom was the worst shower I’ve had since being travelling, the water was always cold and it’s a bath/shower so is just not nice. The free breakfast is cold, and not very nice, the only good thing was the watermelon and the orange juice! Other than this, I thought the staff here were amazing, they were extremely helpful and always happy. One of the best customer services I’ve received since being away! However, they do cancel your bookings on Hostelworld so that you’re unable to leave bad reviews which should of been a red flag 🚩 Rooftop was nice and the free beer every night is a plus!
-
Récompense liée à un avis
-
Acheté confirméTrace du signal
-
Récompense liée à un avis
paid for and essentially over, we presume to stop us leaving review
BEDBUGS! We actually quite enjoyed our stay at the hostel, comfy beds, friendly staff, nice social areas, free drinks each evening, buffet breakfast and fun pub crawl however our room had bedbugs and our booking was cancelled a couple hours before check out when our stay was paid for and essentially over, we presume to stop us leaving review on hostel world. Originally staff were helpful immediately moved me to a new bunk (in the same room) and washed all my stuff that had touched the bed for free. They said they would shut down that bunk but a few hours later it was dressed again for next guest (though no one stayed there for at least another 24hrs). They also mentioned that they had just treated that room for bedbugs and that the person in the bunk before me had come from a hostel with them. Unfortunately despite being helpful to us it gave the impression that they have a bedbug issue that isn’t being dealt with properly and being hidden from guests by not letting us leave Hostelworld review.
-
Récompense liée à un avis
-
Suspicieusement courtTraduit en anglais
This is great!!
excellent!!
England MALE 18-24 -
Suspicieusement court
Excellent
England MALE 18-24 -
Suspicieusement court
Excellent
Netherlands MALE 18-24 -
Suspicieusement court
🤙🏽🤙🏽🤙🏽🤙🏽🤙🏽🤙🏽🤙🏽🤙🏽🤙🏽🤙🏽
Argentina MALE 25-30 -
Suspicieusement court
Cool
-
Suspicieusement court
Legendary
-
Suspicieusement courtTraduit en anglais
This is amazing!!!
Amazing!!!
England MALE 18-24 -
Suspicieusement court
perfectdestroyer
Canada MALE 31-40 -
Suspicieusement court
Brilliant
England MALE 25-30 -
Suspicieusement court
UNBELIEVABLE!!
Ireland MALE 25-30 -
Suspicieusement court
5⭐️service
Australia MALE 18-24 -
Suspicieusement courtTraduit en anglais
I stayed here for seven days, it was a very strange experience for my first time backpacking trip, the service staff here are very patient, every morning breakfast is provided with a rich breakfast, I also know a very cute service person, her name is April, her face is always full of passion and smile, it makes people feel happy, people from the east who want to experience western cultural exchange can come here and experience and see👍👍👍
我在這邊住了七天,這對我第一次來背包旅行是很新奇的體驗,這邊的服務人員都非常有耐心,每天早餐都提供豐富足夠的早餐,我也認識一個非常可愛的服務人員,她名字叫April,她表情都是充滿熱情和笑容,讓人感到愉悅,東方人想體驗西方文化交流可以來這邊體驗看看👍👍👍
Taiwan China MALE -
Suspicieusement court
Legendary
-
Suspicieusement court
Superbe
France -
Suspicieusement court
Gisp,Liam,Henry
Denmark MALE 18-24 -
Suspicieusement court
👍👍👍
Luxembourg MALE 18-24 -
Suspicieusement courtTraduit en anglais
This is fantastic.
Fantástico
Mexico MALE 25-30 -
Suspicieusement court
🤙🤙🤙🤙🤙🤙🤙
France MALE 18-24 -
Suspicieusement courtTraduit en anglais
atmosphere is good, the sexual value is high, the environment is comfortable
氛围好,性价比高,环境舒适
China MALE 25-30
Avis natifs HostelPunk
Notes de terrain directes
Aucun avis HostelPunk natif pour l'instant. Soyez le premier signal.
Analyse de l'ambiance
Le bar sur le toit est le principal attrait: il est social, avec des barres, des boissons avant de sortir, et une terrasse qui convient bien au coucher du soleil ou à la sortie. L'auberge est particulièrement adaptée aux voyageurs en solo. Le personnel est souvent amical et serviable, et le petit déjeuner, l'eau gratuite, les serviettes et un emplacement central dans le district 1 facilitent le déplacement. Les chambres sont mixtes. Certains sont propres et confortables, avec un climatiseur décent, mais d'autres sont rudimentaires, bruyants ou rugueux, surtout dans les salles de bains et sur les lits supérieurs.
Signaux à vérifier
- Le bruit peut venir du toit, du bar et des étages principaux.
- La propreté est inégale dans certaines chambres et salles de bains.
- Certains lits sont très durs, et les lits supérieurs peuvent être difficiles à monter.
- Il n'y a pas d'ascenseur.
- Les réservations et le traitement des paiements peuvent être désordonnés, avec des annulations, des surréservations ou des surprises de prix en espèces.
- Un problème de punaises de lit a été soulevé dans certaines salles.